Identity Crisis? What Identity Crisis?
Thursday, November 27th, 2008The British, we are told, are suffering from a national identity crisis. Who are we? What is it that makes us British? What are our common values? What do we believe about ourselves and our place in the world?
Of course the debate is not new. It has been going on at least since 1962 when US Secretary of State Dean Acheson said, “Britain has lost an empire and has not yet found a role”.
I have bought into this debate, my own take being that our inner loss of confidence and identity is directly attributable to the collective denial of our Judeo-Christian religious roots post-WW2.
But two recent incidents have caused me to pause:
On Saturday I went to a celebration of the election of the new Young Mayor of Newham, Joshua Adejokun, chosen recently by a ballot of all 11 to 18 year olds across the borough. It was held at his place of worship, the Cherubim and Seraphim Church in Forest Gate. Joshua is an attractively self-confident young man of 14 with dread-locks who spoke articulately about his election campaign, his family and his faith. The predominantly Nigerian Pentecostal congregation was exuberantly excited about this success for one of their own, and their joy was reflected in the decibel levels.
In the middle of the celebration, three white-clad ‘Soldiers of Salvation’ marched into the church carrying three flags, in pride of place and easily the largest of which was the Union Jack – not the Nigerian national flag or the church denominational banner, but the red, white and blue of the flag of the United Kingdom. It was saluted, elevated, furled and unfurled, paraded and saluted again before being deposited beside the altar at the front of the church.
Such enthusiastic respect for the symbol of British nationhood by an overwhelmingly ethnic-background congregation was unexpected to say the least.
Then on Monday I attended a lunchtime round-table discussion at the Quilliam Foundation, the organisation recently launched by two former Hizb-ut-Tahrir militants (Ed Husain and Maajid Nawaz) to counter the very Islamic extremism that they themselves once espoused. The theme of the seminar was British Muslims in 2009 – Where Next?
One of the speakers was Sabin Malik, a hijab-wearing young Muslim involved in community work and local government, and an adviser to Hazel Blears MP, the Minister for Community and Local Government. Sabin’s enthusiasm for things British was, again, unexpected, and certainly not the sort of sentiment you would hear from your average guilt-ridden self-loathing left-liberal opinion-former that stalks the corridors of Westminster, Whitehall and White City.
Britain is a great nation, she said. She rates the country’s openness, tolerance and democracy and in her view there is no better place for a modern Muslim woman to live. Her enthusiasm for things English like fish and chips, an ‘Indian’ (curry take-away) and the proverbial cup of tea reminded me of John Major and his description of a Britain at ease with itself – “long shadows on cricket grounds, warm beer, dog lovers, pools-fillers and old maids bicycling to Holy Communion through the morning mist”.
It comes to something, I reflected, when it’s people from ethnic-minority backgrounds who show the rest of us how to have confidence in what it is to be British. In modern multi-cultural Britain I thought it was only the excellent Royal British Legion who displayed such flag-waving patriotism and sincere national gratitude in public. It seems I was wrong.
Our minority-background population to show us the way? It appears that they at least know no identity crisis.