A colleague warned me tersely, “Beware; SOAS ISoc is full of radicals.”
I’d been invited to speak last Friday to the Islamic Society at the School of African and Oriental Studies (SOAS – the “world’s leading centre” for the study of subjects relating to Asia, Africa and the Middle East (here)) in central London, and he was concerned I was walking into a lions’ den full of bearded Islamic fundamentalists.
I didn’t mind if I was, but in the event the ISoc members were friendly guys who, if they had beards at all, they were more designer stubble than fist-length.
They invited me to talk about “What I would like Muslims to know about Christianity”. The ISoc organisers had outsourced the Islamic side of the discussion to an outfit called Muslim Debate Initiative (here) whose leading light, Sami Zaatari, was similarly asked to tell the meeting what he would like Christians to know about Islam.
I looked forward to the opportunity to talk full-length about Truth, Love and Jesus Christ – but I was also fascinated by Sami’s conundrum. I’ve engaged with MDI before, having debated in the past with both Sami – who is courteous and serious-minded – and Abdullah al Andalusi and having crossed swords with English convert Paul Williams when, nauseatingly, he salivated on his blog about the “hot-topic” of executing apostates (here). Suddenly exposed and embarrassed by his adopted Islamic morality, he was forced to take down his post.
MDI is seen as a fundamentalist organisation by progressive Muslims and certainly MDI’s usual debating tactics are taken from the confrontational ‘attack-is-the-best-form-of-defence’ school. They prefer to critique the beliefs of opponents (Christians, atheists or anyone else) than to justify Islam. Although limited, there’s nothing wrong with that method during formal debates where part of the skill is to not only persuade the audience of the strength of your own position but also to highlight the weakness of your opponent’s.
But ISoc’s meeting on Friday was not a debate. Rather, the organisers made clear, Sami and I were each to be given 25 minutes to explain our respective faiths and then we were simply to answer questions from the audience. Sami was not to talk about Christianity and I wouldn’t discuss Islam.
This, I predicted to friends, would be a problem for him. Sami is an arch-exponent of the MDI attack-dog approach; he’s never more comfortable than when he is attempting to stick the knife into Christianity. Yet SOAS ISoc was limiting him to one-sidedly promoting Islam.
And he had another problem: in its fundamentalist form Islam is a parasitical religion – like a tick on a dog but more so. It doesn’t have the spiritual, moral or intellectual capacity to stand alone and subsist by itself. Rather it has to have an ‘other’ from which it can suck life and vitality and against which it can measure and express itself. It cannot live peaceably alongside others. It defines itself by hostility to the ‘other’ which it has to take over, suck dry and either dominate or destroy, if necessary by force.
That’s why, globally, wherever fundamentalist Islam arrives on the scene, inevitably in due course there is conflict. Central Nigeria illustrates this dynamic: Jos, for decades a peaceful and popular Christian-majority city, is currently being torn apart by the influx of hard-line Islam from the Sharia states of the Hausa and Fulani north (here).
So given the spiritual and intellectual poverty of his Islam, what would Sami talk about? He had an uninterrupted 25-minute opportunity to promote his beliefs in front of a friendly attentive audience; what would he tell them?
In the event of course, not a lot. Precluded from his default position of attacking Christianity, he spoke for just 16 minutes about Islam… and then dried up. Despite all his speaking experience and all his commitment to his religion, he had nothing more to say. When the ISoc moderator indicated he had another 9 minutes to speak, he declined.
His lack of words summed up the emptiness of his Islam, truly a belief system worth only 16 minutes.
Happy Christ-mas!
Posted in Christianity, Christmas, Islam, Religious/Politics | 6 Comments »



















